Saltar a contenido

weekly · 2026-10-19 08:38 UTC

Ejecución semanal de todos los solvers registrados sobre la suite v1 (54 instancias de Pisinger con óptimo).

Parámetro Valor
Commit 85fe5ab
Ejecuciones 12960 (54 instancias × 8 solvers × 30 semillas desde 1), 360 fallidas
Presupuesto por ejecución 50000 evaluaciones, 10 s
Calentamiento por solver 2 (no se registran)
Orden barajado con semilla 1
Ejecución un proceso por solver; límite duro: presupuesto de tiempo + 5 s
Entorno Intel(R) Xeon(R) 6973P-C · 4 núcleos · Java 25.0.4.1 (Eclipse Adoptium) · Linux 6.17.0-1022-azure amd64
Duración 468 s
Conjunto de instancias 517a1868
Datos manifest.json · runs.jsonl · summary.csv

Solvers

Solver Autor declarado Autores en git Código
discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy Jorge Herrera Franklin Daniel Morfa Vega 57ca2dc5
exact/dynamic-programming baseline Daniel Morfa Vega 22c0a2e5
greedy/ratio baseline Daniel Morfa Vega 94498bdc
greedy/ratio-best-item baseline Daniel Morfa Vega 8133d093
harmony-search/legacy Jorge Herrera Franklin Daniel Morfa Vega e21c9708
hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy Daniel Morfa Vega Daniel Morfa Vega 957f17a5
hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy Jorge Herrera Franklin Daniel Morfa Vega ac530ff5
improved-harmony-search/legacy Jorge Herrera Franklin Daniel Morfa Vega 24bc55f9

La huella es el SHA-256 de las fuentes de las que depende cada solver; la lista completa está en manifest.json. Los autores en git son los de sus fuentes, sin knapsack-core ni knapsack-bench.

Cómo leer esta página

El GAP es 100 · (referencia − beneficio) / referencia: la referencia es el óptimo conocido o, si falta, la cota de Dantzig, y entonces el GAP se marca con ≤. Las métricas de calidad usan solo las ejecuciones correctas. Los tiempos solo son comparables dentro de esta misma ejecución: cambian con la máquina.

Clasificación global

Prueba de Friedman sobre el GAP mediano de cada solver en cada instancia: χ² = 343.615, p = 2.9e-70. Hay diferencias significativas entre los solvers (α = 0.05).

Posición Solver Autor Rango medio Media de GAP medianos
1 exact/dynamic-programming baseline 1.11 0.00 %
2 greedy/ratio baseline 2.44 0.46 %
3 greedy/ratio-best-item baseline 2.44 0.46 %
4 improved-harmony-search/legacy Jorge Herrera Franklin 4.94 19.61 %
5 discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy Jorge Herrera Franklin 5.10 19.31 %
6 harmony-search/legacy Jorge Herrera Franklin 5.29 19.47 %
7 hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy Jorge Herrera Franklin 6.89 22.56 % (sin ejecuciones correctas en 12)
8 hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy Daniel Morfa Vega 7.78 94.88 %

Diferencia crítica de Nemenyi (α = 0.05): 1.429. Dos solvers cuyos rangos medios difieren menos que ese valor no se distinguen estadísticamente.

Comparaciones por pares

Prueba de Wilcoxon de rangos con signo sobre los GAP medianos por instancia, con corrección de Holm para 28 comparaciones. 23 pares muestran una diferencia significativa (α = 0.05).

Ver los 28 pares
Solver A Solver B A gana / pierde / empata p p (Holm) Conclusión
discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy exact/dynamic-programming 0 / 54 / 0 1.7e-10 ≈ 4.1e-09 mejor exact/dynamic-programming
discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy greedy/ratio 0 / 54 / 0 1.7e-10 ≈ 4.1e-09 mejor greedy/ratio
discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy greedy/ratio-best-item 0 / 54 / 0 1.7e-10 ≈ 4.1e-09 mejor greedy/ratio-best-item
discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy harmony-search/legacy 30 / 23 / 1 0.149 ≈ 0.745 sin diferencia significativa
discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy 54 / 0 / 0 1.7e-10 ≈ 4.1e-09 mejor discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy
discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy 49 / 5 / 0 7.8e-08 ≈ 5.5e-07 mejor discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy
discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy improved-harmony-search/legacy 23 / 31 / 0 0.724 ≈ 1.000 sin diferencia significativa
exact/dynamic-programming greedy/ratio 48 / 0 / 6 7.1e-15 2.0e-13 mejor exact/dynamic-programming
exact/dynamic-programming greedy/ratio-best-item 48 / 0 / 6 7.1e-15 2.0e-13 mejor exact/dynamic-programming
exact/dynamic-programming harmony-search/legacy 54 / 0 / 0 1.7e-10 ≈ 4.1e-09 mejor exact/dynamic-programming
exact/dynamic-programming hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy 54 / 0 / 0 1.7e-10 ≈ 4.1e-09 mejor exact/dynamic-programming
exact/dynamic-programming hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy 54 / 0 / 0 1.6e-10 ≈ 4.1e-09 mejor exact/dynamic-programming
exact/dynamic-programming improved-harmony-search/legacy 54 / 0 / 0 1.7e-10 ≈ 4.1e-09 mejor exact/dynamic-programming
greedy/ratio greedy/ratio-best-item 0 / 0 / 54 1.000 1.000 sin diferencia significativa
greedy/ratio harmony-search/legacy 54 / 0 / 0 1.7e-10 ≈ 4.1e-09 mejor greedy/ratio
greedy/ratio hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy 54 / 0 / 0 1.7e-10 ≈ 4.1e-09 mejor greedy/ratio
greedy/ratio hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy 54 / 0 / 0 1.6e-10 ≈ 4.1e-09 mejor greedy/ratio
greedy/ratio improved-harmony-search/legacy 54 / 0 / 0 1.7e-10 ≈ 4.1e-09 mejor greedy/ratio
greedy/ratio-best-item harmony-search/legacy 54 / 0 / 0 1.7e-10 ≈ 4.1e-09 mejor greedy/ratio-best-item
greedy/ratio-best-item hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy 54 / 0 / 0 1.7e-10 ≈ 4.1e-09 mejor greedy/ratio-best-item
greedy/ratio-best-item hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy 54 / 0 / 0 1.6e-10 ≈ 4.1e-09 mejor greedy/ratio-best-item
greedy/ratio-best-item improved-harmony-search/legacy 54 / 0 / 0 1.7e-10 ≈ 4.1e-09 mejor greedy/ratio-best-item
harmony-search/legacy hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy 54 / 0 / 0 1.7e-10 ≈ 4.1e-09 mejor harmony-search/legacy
harmony-search/legacy hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy 46 / 8 / 0 2.3e-07 ≈ 1.4e-06 mejor harmony-search/legacy
harmony-search/legacy improved-harmony-search/legacy 23 / 31 / 0 0.877 ≈ 1.000 sin diferencia significativa
hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy 12 / 42 / 0 0.168 ≈ 0.745 sin diferencia significativa
hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy improved-harmony-search/legacy 0 / 54 / 0 1.7e-10 ≈ 4.1e-09 mejor improved-harmony-search/legacy
hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy improved-harmony-search/legacy 5 / 49 / 0 2.1e-08 ≈ 1.7e-07 mejor improved-harmony-search/legacy

Resultados por instancia

almost-strongly-correlated-n1000-r1000-h25of100-s1

1000 objetos · capacidad 128820 · óptimo 177316 · instances/suite-v1/almost-strongly-correlated-n1000-r1000-h25of100-s1.json

Solver Correctas Mejor GAP mediano GAP mínimo Óptimos Evaluaciones Hasta el mejor ms
exact/dynamic-programming 30/30 177316 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 1 1 116.73
greedy/ratio 30/30 177243 0.04 % 0.04 % 0 1 1 0.19
greedy/ratio-best-item 30/30 177243 0.04 % 0.04 % 0 2 1 0.19
improved-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 154875 13.21 % 12.66 % 0 21280 1388 86.03
harmony-search/legacy 30/30 154978 13.28 % 12.60 % 0 21169 1236 86.05
discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 155841 13.32 % 12.11 % 0 21266 751 68.91
hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy 30/30 1464 99.17 % 99.17 % 0 20022 3401 19.57
hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy 0/30 — — — 0 — — —

almost-strongly-correlated-n1000-r1000-h50of100-s1

1000 objetos · capacidad 257641 · óptimo 327165 · instances/suite-v1/almost-strongly-correlated-n1000-r1000-h50of100-s1.json

Solver Correctas Mejor GAP mediano GAP mínimo Óptimos Evaluaciones Hasta el mejor ms
exact/dynamic-programming 30/30 327165 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 1 1 275.78
greedy/ratio 30/30 326531 0.19 % 0.19 % 0 1 1 0.18
greedy/ratio-best-item 30/30 326531 0.19 % 0.19 % 0 2 1 0.18
harmony-search/legacy 30/30 308251 6.24 % 5.78 % 0 656 16 4.71
discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 307712 6.31 % 5.95 % 0 686 26 3.91
improved-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 308683 6.42 % 5.65 % 0 766 23 5.21
hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy 30/30 307359 7.88 % 6.05 % 0 23 14 0.17
hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy 30/30 1464 99.55 % 99.55 % 0 20022 3401 19.59

almost-strongly-correlated-n1000-r1000-h75of100-s1

1000 objetos · capacidad 386462 · óptimo 472189 · instances/suite-v1/almost-strongly-correlated-n1000-r1000-h75of100-s1.json

Solver Correctas Mejor GAP mediano GAP mínimo Óptimos Evaluaciones Hasta el mejor ms
exact/dynamic-programming 30/30 472189 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 1 1 449.09
greedy/ratio 30/30 472157 0.01 % 0.01 % 0 1 1 0.17
greedy/ratio-best-item 30/30 472157 0.01 % 0.01 % 0 2 1 0.17
harmony-search/legacy 30/30 339589 30.62 % 28.08 % 0 698 7 5.99
discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 348460 30.74 % 26.20 % 0 698 7 5.66
improved-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 333968 32.95 % 29.27 % 0 118 1 2.07
hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy 30/30 328664 33.95 % 30.40 % 0 22 11 0.14
hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy 30/30 1464 99.69 % 99.69 % 0 20022 3401 19.57

almost-strongly-correlated-n200-r1000-h25of100-s1

200 objetos · capacidad 25292 · óptimo 34824 · instances/suite-v1/almost-strongly-correlated-n200-r1000-h25of100-s1.json

Solver Correctas Mejor GAP mediano GAP mínimo Óptimos Evaluaciones Hasta el mejor ms
exact/dynamic-programming 30/30 34824 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 1 1 5.17
greedy/ratio 30/30 34325 1.43 % 1.43 % 0 1 1 0.05
greedy/ratio-best-item 30/30 34325 1.43 % 1.43 % 0 2 1 0.06
improved-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 31049 13.18 % 10.84 % 0 4477 299 4.08
harmony-search/legacy 30/30 30631 14.17 % 12.04 % 0 4361 152 3.99
discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 30734 14.22 % 11.74 % 0 4375 169 3.29
hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy 30/30 1754 94.96 % 94.96 % 0 4022 769 1.24
hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy 0/30 — — — 0 — — —

almost-strongly-correlated-n200-r1000-h50of100-s1

200 objetos · capacidad 50585 · óptimo 64435 · instances/suite-v1/almost-strongly-correlated-n200-r1000-h50of100-s1.json

Solver Correctas Mejor GAP mediano GAP mínimo Óptimos Evaluaciones Hasta el mejor ms
exact/dynamic-programming 30/30 64435 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 1 1 11.64
greedy/ratio 30/30 63976 0.71 % 0.71 % 0 1 1 0.05
greedy/ratio-best-item 30/30 63976 0.71 % 0.71 % 0 2 1 0.06
improved-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 61238 6.66 % 4.96 % 0 486 14 0.83
discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 60541 7.22 % 6.04 % 0 348 11 0.57
harmony-search/legacy 30/30 61076 7.39 % 5.21 % 0 348 11 0.67
hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy 30/30 61159 8.91 % 5.08 % 0 22 11 0.04
hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy 30/30 1754 97.28 % 97.28 % 0 4022 769 1.24

almost-strongly-correlated-n200-r1000-h75of100-s1

200 objetos · capacidad 75878 · óptimo 93021 · instances/suite-v1/almost-strongly-correlated-n200-r1000-h75of100-s1.json

Solver Correctas Mejor GAP mediano GAP mínimo Óptimos Evaluaciones Hasta el mejor ms
exact/dynamic-programming 30/30 93021 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 1 1 18.56
greedy/ratio 30/30 92775 0.26 % 0.26 % 0 1 1 0.06
greedy/ratio-best-item 30/30 92775 0.26 % 0.26 % 0 2 1 0.05
harmony-search/legacy 30/30 74721 26.13 % 19.67 % 0 698 6 1.11
discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 75602 27.26 % 18.73 % 0 698 5 1.07
improved-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 75335 27.84 % 19.01 % 0 234 2 0.58
hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy 30/30 73547 33.28 % 20.94 % 0 22 10 0.04
hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy 30/30 1754 98.11 % 98.11 % 0 4022 769 1.24

almost-strongly-correlated-n50-r1000-h25of100-s1

50 objetos · capacidad 6081 · óptimo 8385 · instances/suite-v1/almost-strongly-correlated-n50-r1000-h25of100-s1.json

Solver Correctas Mejor GAP mediano GAP mínimo Óptimos Evaluaciones Hasta el mejor ms
exact/dynamic-programming 30/30 8385 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 1 1 0.32
greedy/ratio 30/30 8015 4.41 % 4.41 % 0 1 1 0.04
greedy/ratio-best-item 30/30 8015 4.41 % 4.41 % 0 2 1 0.03
hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy 30/30 7959 10.99 % 5.08 % 0 1159 1147 1.39
improved-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 7821 13.67 % 6.73 % 0 1422 86 0.49
harmony-search/legacy 30/30 7674 14.59 % 8.48 % 0 1214 63 0.42
discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 7660 15.24 % 8.65 % 0 1187 57 0.36
hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy 30/30 2022 75.89 % 75.89 % 0 1022 203 0.19

almost-strongly-correlated-n50-r1000-h50of100-s1

50 objetos · capacidad 12162 · óptimo 15570 · instances/suite-v1/almost-strongly-correlated-n50-r1000-h50of100-s1.json

Solver Correctas Mejor GAP mediano GAP mínimo Óptimos Evaluaciones Hasta el mejor ms
exact/dynamic-programming 30/30 15570 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 1 1 0.74
greedy/ratio 30/30 15132 2.81 % 2.81 % 0 1 1 0.04
greedy/ratio-best-item 30/30 15132 2.81 % 2.81 % 0 2 1 0.04
improved-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 14962 7.61 % 3.90 % 0 485 14 0.24
discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 14819 9.47 % 4.82 % 0 342 9 0.17
harmony-search/legacy 30/30 14777 9.70 % 5.09 % 0 225 5 0.16
hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy 30/30 14805 9.83 % 4.91 % 0 22 11 0.02
hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy 30/30 2022 87.01 % 87.01 % 0 1022 203 0.19

almost-strongly-correlated-n50-r1000-h75of100-s1

50 objetos · capacidad 18244 · óptimo 22540 · instances/suite-v1/almost-strongly-correlated-n50-r1000-h75of100-s1.json

Solver Correctas Mejor GAP mediano GAP mínimo Óptimos Evaluaciones Hasta el mejor ms
exact/dynamic-programming 30/30 22540 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 1 1 1.18
greedy/ratio 30/30 22525 0.07 % 0.07 % 0 1 1 0.03
greedy/ratio-best-item 30/30 22525 0.07 % 0.07 % 0 2 1 0.03
discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 20857 19.71 % 7.47 % 0 638 4 0.28
harmony-search/legacy 30/30 19818 21.46 % 12.08 % 0 638 4 0.28
improved-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 20384 23.70 % 9.57 % 0 408 3 0.23
hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy 30/30 20049 27.66 % 11.05 % 0 22 12 0.02
hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy 30/30 2022 91.03 % 91.03 % 0 1022 203 0.19

inverse-strongly-correlated-n1000-r1000-h25of100-s1

1000 objetos · capacidad 149990 · óptimo 135190 · instances/suite-v1/inverse-strongly-correlated-n1000-r1000-h25of100-s1.json

Solver Correctas Mejor GAP mediano GAP mínimo Óptimos Evaluaciones Hasta el mejor ms
exact/dynamic-programming 30/30 135190 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 1 1 79.11
greedy/ratio 30/30 135190 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 1 1 0.17
greedy/ratio-best-item 30/30 135190 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 2 1 0.18
harmony-search/legacy 30/30 126422 7.30 % 6.49 % 0 21203 736 85.65
improved-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 126202 7.35 % 6.65 % 0 21288 806 86.42
discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 126747 7.36 % 6.25 % 0 21230 773 68.71
hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy 30/30 1492 98.90 % 98.90 % 0 20022 2833 19.62
hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy 0/30 — — — 0 — — —

inverse-strongly-correlated-n1000-r1000-h50of100-s1

1000 objetos · capacidad 299981 · óptimo 267881 · instances/suite-v1/inverse-strongly-correlated-n1000-r1000-h50of100-s1.json

Solver Correctas Mejor GAP mediano GAP mínimo Óptimos Evaluaciones Hasta el mejor ms
exact/dynamic-programming 30/30 267881 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 1 1 221.33
greedy/ratio 30/30 267880 0.00 % 0.00 % 0 1 1 0.18
greedy/ratio-best-item 30/30 267880 0.00 % 0.00 % 0 2 1 0.17
harmony-search/legacy 30/30 251898 6.54 % 5.97 % 0 728 35 4.95
discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 252055 6.57 % 5.91 % 0 667 36 3.92
improved-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 251127 6.59 % 6.25 % 0 767 30 5.40
hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy 30/30 250903 7.69 % 6.34 % 0 23 10 0.17
hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy 30/30 1492 99.44 % 99.44 % 0 20022 2833 19.58

inverse-strongly-correlated-n1000-r1000-h75of100-s1

1000 objetos · capacidad 449972 · óptimo 395572 · instances/suite-v1/inverse-strongly-correlated-n1000-r1000-h75of100-s1.json

Solver Correctas Mejor GAP mediano GAP mínimo Óptimos Evaluaciones Hasta el mejor ms
exact/dynamic-programming 30/30 395572 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 1 1 398.31
greedy/ratio 30/30 395571 0.00 % 0.00 % 0 1 1 0.18
greedy/ratio-best-item 30/30 395571 0.00 % 0.00 % 0 2 1 0.19
harmony-search/legacy 30/30 282565 32.40 % 28.57 % 0 698 6 5.98
discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 276959 32.53 % 29.99 % 0 698 6 5.69
improved-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 268803 35.70 % 32.05 % 0 118 2 2.06
hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy 30/30 268485 36.33 % 32.13 % 0 22 13 0.15
hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy 30/30 1492 99.62 % 99.62 % 0 20022 2833 19.60

inverse-strongly-correlated-n200-r1000-h25of100-s1

200 objetos · capacidad 30062 · óptimo 26962 · instances/suite-v1/inverse-strongly-correlated-n200-r1000-h25of100-s1.json

Solver Correctas Mejor GAP mediano GAP mínimo Óptimos Evaluaciones Hasta el mejor ms
exact/dynamic-programming 30/30 26962 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 1 1 3.63
greedy/ratio 30/30 26954 0.03 % 0.03 % 0 1 1 0.06
greedy/ratio-best-item 30/30 26954 0.03 % 0.03 % 0 2 1 0.05
improved-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 25833 6.94 % 4.19 % 0 4453 327 4.07
discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 25532 7.68 % 5.30 % 0 4374 160 3.28
harmony-search/legacy 30/30 25619 7.71 % 4.98 % 0 4373 171 4.00
hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy 30/30 1303 95.17 % 95.17 % 0 4022 783 1.23
hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy 0/30 — — — 0 — — —

inverse-strongly-correlated-n200-r1000-h50of100-s1

200 objetos · capacidad 60124 · óptimo 53424 · instances/suite-v1/inverse-strongly-correlated-n200-r1000-h50of100-s1.json

Solver Correctas Mejor GAP mediano GAP mínimo Óptimos Evaluaciones Hasta el mejor ms
exact/dynamic-programming 30/30 53424 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 1 1 9.10
greedy/ratio 30/30 53423 0.00 % 0.00 % 0 1 1 0.06
greedy/ratio-best-item 30/30 53423 0.00 % 0.00 % 0 2 1 0.06
improved-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 50863 5.96 % 4.79 % 0 470 21 0.82
discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 50715 6.75 % 5.07 % 0 358 17 0.58
harmony-search/legacy 30/30 50864 6.89 % 4.79 % 0 304 9 0.64
hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy 30/30 50918 10.92 % 4.69 % 0 22 16 0.04
hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy 30/30 1303 97.56 % 97.56 % 0 4022 783 1.23

inverse-strongly-correlated-n200-r1000-h75of100-s1

200 objetos · capacidad 90187 · óptimo 79077 · instances/suite-v1/inverse-strongly-correlated-n200-r1000-h75of100-s1.json

Solver Correctas Mejor GAP mediano GAP mínimo Óptimos Evaluaciones Hasta el mejor ms
exact/dynamic-programming 30/30 79077 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 1 1 16.04
greedy/ratio 30/30 79077 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 1 1 0.07
greedy/ratio-best-item 30/30 79077 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 2 1 0.07
discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 62185 27.80 % 21.36 % 0 698 5 1.07
harmony-search/legacy 30/30 60731 28.68 % 23.20 % 0 698 5 1.13
improved-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 59023 32.03 % 25.36 % 0 263 3 0.64
hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy 30/30 59935 33.08 % 24.21 % 0 22 10 0.04
hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy 30/30 1303 98.35 % 98.35 % 0 4022 783 1.24

inverse-strongly-correlated-n50-r1000-h25of100-s1

50 objetos · capacidad 7423 · óptimo 6623 · instances/suite-v1/inverse-strongly-correlated-n50-r1000-h25of100-s1.json

Solver Correctas Mejor GAP mediano GAP mínimo Óptimos Evaluaciones Hasta el mejor ms
exact/dynamic-programming 30/30 6623 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 1 1 0.30
greedy/ratio 30/30 6615 0.12 % 0.12 % 0 1 1 0.03
greedy/ratio-best-item 30/30 6615 0.12 % 0.12 % 0 2 1 0.03
improved-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 6284 8.70 % 5.12 % 0 1288 83 0.45
harmony-search/legacy 30/30 6348 8.75 % 4.15 % 0 1196 50 0.43
discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 6284 8.99 % 5.12 % 0 1206 53 0.37
hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy 30/30 6178 11.73 % 6.72 % 0 2146 2139 2.57
hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy 30/30 1020 84.60 % 84.60 % 0 1022 129 0.20

inverse-strongly-correlated-n50-r1000-h50of100-s1

50 objetos · capacidad 14847 · óptimo 13047 · instances/suite-v1/inverse-strongly-correlated-n50-r1000-h50of100-s1.json

Solver Correctas Mejor GAP mediano GAP mínimo Óptimos Evaluaciones Hasta el mejor ms
exact/dynamic-programming 30/30 13047 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 1 1 0.71
greedy/ratio 30/30 12974 0.56 % 0.56 % 0 1 1 0.03
greedy/ratio-best-item 30/30 12974 0.56 % 0.56 % 0 2 1 0.03
improved-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 12694 5.64 % 2.71 % 0 478 22 0.25
discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 12479 6.51 % 4.35 % 0 285 9 0.16
harmony-search/legacy 30/30 12553 7.19 % 3.79 % 0 215 9 0.16
hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy 30/30 12516 7.81 % 4.07 % 0 22 10 0.02
hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy 30/30 1020 92.18 % 92.18 % 0 1022 129 0.20

inverse-strongly-correlated-n50-r1000-h75of100-s1

50 objetos · capacidad 22270 · óptimo 19270 · instances/suite-v1/inverse-strongly-correlated-n50-r1000-h75of100-s1.json

Solver Correctas Mejor GAP mediano GAP mínimo Óptimos Evaluaciones Hasta el mejor ms
exact/dynamic-programming 30/30 19270 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 1 1 1.18
greedy/ratio 30/30 19238 0.17 % 0.17 % 0 1 1 0.04
greedy/ratio-best-item 30/30 19238 0.17 % 0.17 % 0 2 1 0.04
discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 18409 18.87 % 4.47 % 0 638 6 0.28
harmony-search/legacy 30/30 18745 18.87 % 2.72 % 0 578 6 0.27
improved-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 18543 23.90 % 3.77 % 0 437 4 0.23
hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy 30/30 18589 29.98 % 3.53 % 0 22 8 0.02
hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy 30/30 1020 94.71 % 94.71 % 0 1022 129 0.20

strongly-correlated-n1000-r1000-h25of100-s1

1000 objetos · capacidad 125238 · óptimo 173938 · instances/suite-v1/strongly-correlated-n1000-r1000-h25of100-s1.json

Solver Correctas Mejor GAP mediano GAP mínimo Óptimos Evaluaciones Hasta el mejor ms
exact/dynamic-programming 30/30 173938 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 1 1 87.11
greedy/ratio 30/30 173886 0.03 % 0.03 % 0 1 1 0.18
greedy/ratio-best-item 30/30 173886 0.03 % 0.03 % 0 2 1 0.18
improved-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 151983 13.68 % 12.62 % 0 21372 1327 86.72
discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 151317 13.72 % 13.01 % 0 21201 983 68.94
harmony-search/legacy 30/30 151287 13.81 % 13.02 % 0 21213 760 85.75
hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy 30/30 1692 99.03 % 99.03 % 0 20022 2833 19.67
hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy 0/30 — — — 0 — — —

strongly-correlated-n1000-r1000-h50of100-s1

1000 objetos · capacidad 250476 · óptimo 320176 · instances/suite-v1/strongly-correlated-n1000-r1000-h50of100-s1.json

Solver Correctas Mejor GAP mediano GAP mínimo Óptimos Evaluaciones Hasta el mejor ms
exact/dynamic-programming 30/30 320176 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 1 1 210.66
greedy/ratio 30/30 319595 0.18 % 0.18 % 0 1 1 0.18
greedy/ratio-best-item 30/30 319595 0.18 % 0.18 % 0 2 1 0.18
discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 300270 6.44 % 6.22 % 0 752 34 4.15
improved-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 301173 6.55 % 5.94 % 0 719 26 4.99
harmony-search/legacy 30/30 301134 6.59 % 5.95 % 0 728 13 5.05
hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy 30/30 301067 7.61 % 5.97 % 0 23 14 0.17
hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy 30/30 1692 99.47 % 99.47 % 0 20022 2833 19.60

strongly-correlated-n1000-r1000-h75of100-s1

1000 objetos · capacidad 375715 · óptimo 461515 · instances/suite-v1/strongly-correlated-n1000-r1000-h75of100-s1.json

Solver Correctas Mejor GAP mediano GAP mínimo Óptimos Evaluaciones Hasta el mejor ms
exact/dynamic-programming 30/30 461515 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 1 1 360.71
greedy/ratio 30/30 460850 0.14 % 0.14 % 0 1 1 0.17
greedy/ratio-best-item 30/30 460850 0.14 % 0.14 % 0 2 1 0.17
harmony-search/legacy 30/30 330443 30.58 % 28.40 % 0 698 8 5.98
discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 329202 30.97 % 28.67 % 0 698 7 5.68
improved-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 333178 32.69 % 27.81 % 0 118 1 2.07
hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy 30/30 321161 34.56 % 30.41 % 0 22 7 0.14
hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy 30/30 1692 99.63 % 99.63 % 0 20022 2833 19.63

strongly-correlated-n200-r1000-h25of100-s1

200 objetos · capacidad 25111 · óptimo 34511 · instances/suite-v1/strongly-correlated-n200-r1000-h25of100-s1.json

Solver Correctas Mejor GAP mediano GAP mínimo Óptimos Evaluaciones Hasta el mejor ms
exact/dynamic-programming 30/30 34511 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 1 1 4.11
greedy/ratio 30/30 34228 0.82 % 0.82 % 0 1 1 0.06
greedy/ratio-best-item 30/30 34228 0.82 % 0.82 % 0 2 1 0.06
improved-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 30599 12.60 % 11.34 % 0 4419 253 4.02
harmony-search/legacy 30/30 30700 13.52 % 11.04 % 0 4363 163 4.01
discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 30710 13.61 % 11.01 % 0 4394 184 3.30
hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy 30/30 1503 95.64 % 95.64 % 0 4022 783 1.25
hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy 0/30 — — — 0 — — —

strongly-correlated-n200-r1000-h50of100-s1

200 objetos · capacidad 50223 · óptimo 63923 · instances/suite-v1/strongly-correlated-n200-r1000-h50of100-s1.json

Solver Correctas Mejor GAP mediano GAP mínimo Óptimos Evaluaciones Hasta el mejor ms
exact/dynamic-programming 30/30 63923 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 1 1 9.32
greedy/ratio 30/30 63803 0.19 % 0.19 % 0 1 1 0.06
greedy/ratio-best-item 30/30 63803 0.19 % 0.19 % 0 2 1 0.06
improved-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 60579 6.52 % 5.23 % 0 466 18 0.82
discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 60685 6.74 % 5.07 % 0 355 10 0.58
harmony-search/legacy 30/30 60112 7.25 % 5.96 % 0 357 10 0.65
hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy 30/30 60656 8.98 % 5.11 % 0 22 15 0.04
hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy 30/30 1503 97.65 % 97.65 % 0 4022 783 1.25

strongly-correlated-n200-r1000-h75of100-s1

200 objetos · capacidad 75335 · óptimo 92335 · instances/suite-v1/strongly-correlated-n200-r1000-h75of100-s1.json

Solver Correctas Mejor GAP mediano GAP mínimo Óptimos Evaluaciones Hasta el mejor ms
exact/dynamic-programming 30/30 92335 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 1 1 15.24
greedy/ratio 30/30 91724 0.66 % 0.66 % 0 1 1 0.07
greedy/ratio-best-item 30/30 91724 0.66 % 0.66 % 0 2 1 0.05
harmony-search/legacy 30/30 73833 26.09 % 20.04 % 0 698 5 1.12
discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 72823 26.36 % 21.13 % 0 698 6 1.07
improved-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 73993 29.46 % 19.86 % 0 234 3 0.57
hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy 30/30 71376 32.78 % 22.70 % 0 22 11 0.04
hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy 30/30 1503 98.37 % 98.37 % 0 4022 783 1.23

strongly-correlated-n50-r1000-h25of100-s1

50 objetos · capacidad 6185 · óptimo 8285 · instances/suite-v1/strongly-correlated-n50-r1000-h25of100-s1.json

Solver Correctas Mejor GAP mediano GAP mínimo Óptimos Evaluaciones Hasta el mejor ms
exact/dynamic-programming 30/30 8285 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 1 1 0.31
greedy/ratio 30/30 7853 5.21 % 5.21 % 0 1 1 0.04
greedy/ratio-best-item 30/30 7853 5.21 % 5.21 % 0 2 1 0.04
hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy 30/30 7869 9.53 % 5.02 % 0 981 971 1.18
improved-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 7680 11.35 % 7.30 % 0 1334 79 0.45
harmony-search/legacy 30/30 7610 12.06 % 8.15 % 0 1222 60 0.42
discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 7573 13.40 % 8.59 % 0 1195 38 0.35
hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy 30/30 1220 85.27 % 85.27 % 0 1022 129 0.19

strongly-correlated-n50-r1000-h50of100-s1

50 objetos · capacidad 12371 · óptimo 15671 · instances/suite-v1/strongly-correlated-n50-r1000-h50of100-s1.json

Solver Correctas Mejor GAP mediano GAP mínimo Óptimos Evaluaciones Hasta el mejor ms
exact/dynamic-programming 30/30 15671 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 1 1 0.71
greedy/ratio 30/30 15424 1.58 % 1.58 % 0 1 1 0.05
greedy/ratio-best-item 30/30 15424 1.58 % 1.58 % 0 2 1 0.03
improved-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 15042 6.40 % 4.01 % 0 474 8 0.23
discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 14983 6.47 % 4.39 % 0 295 10 0.16
hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy 30/30 15063 7.43 % 3.88 % 0 21 10 0.02
harmony-search/legacy 30/30 15152 8.23 % 3.31 % 0 231 5 0.17
hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy 30/30 1220 92.21 % 92.21 % 0 1022 129 0.19

strongly-correlated-n50-r1000-h75of100-s1

50 objetos · capacidad 18557 · óptimo 22757 · instances/suite-v1/strongly-correlated-n50-r1000-h75of100-s1.json

Solver Correctas Mejor GAP mediano GAP mínimo Óptimos Evaluaciones Hasta el mejor ms
exact/dynamic-programming 30/30 22757 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 1 1 1.14
greedy/ratio 30/30 22317 1.93 % 1.93 % 0 1 1 0.04
greedy/ratio-best-item 30/30 22317 1.93 % 1.93 % 0 2 1 0.03
harmony-search/legacy 30/30 21642 18.99 % 4.90 % 0 578 5 0.27
discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 21091 19.40 % 7.32 % 0 638 7 0.27
improved-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 21609 20.85 % 5.04 % 0 408 4 0.21
hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy 30/30 21804 30.46 % 4.19 % 0 22 11 0.02
hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy 30/30 1220 94.64 % 94.64 % 0 1022 129 0.21

subset-sum-n1000-r1000-h25of100-s1

1000 objetos · capacidad 125238 · óptimo 125238 · instances/suite-v1/subset-sum-n1000-r1000-h25of100-s1.json

Solver Correctas Mejor GAP mediano GAP mínimo Óptimos Evaluaciones Hasta el mejor ms
exact/dynamic-programming 30/30 125238 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 1 1 56.83
greedy/ratio 30/30 125238 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 1 1 0.05
greedy/ratio-best-item 30/30 125238 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 2 1 0.04
harmony-search/legacy 30/30 125227 0.14 % 0.01 % 0 21243 769 86.12
improved-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 125235 0.16 % 0.00 % 0 21402 791 86.87
discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 125235 0.20 % 0.00 % 0 21179 789 68.78
hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy 30/30 1492 98.81 % 98.81 % 0 20022 2833 19.61
hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy 0/30 — — — 0 — — —

subset-sum-n1000-r1000-h50of100-s1

1000 objetos · capacidad 250476 · óptimo 250476 · instances/suite-v1/subset-sum-n1000-r1000-h50of100-s1.json

Solver Correctas Mejor GAP mediano GAP mínimo Óptimos Evaluaciones Hasta el mejor ms
exact/dynamic-programming 30/30 250476 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 1 1 149.71
greedy/ratio 30/30 250466 0.00 % 0.00 % 0 1 1 0.05
greedy/ratio-best-item 30/30 250466 0.00 % 0.00 % 0 2 1 0.04
improved-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 250416 0.21 % 0.02 % 0 752 25 5.08
discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 250421 0.22 % 0.02 % 0 746 20 4.19
harmony-search/legacy 30/30 250418 0.27 % 0.02 % 0 759 25 5.12
hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy 30/30 250453 1.84 % 0.01 % 0 23 14 0.17
hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy 30/30 1492 99.40 % 99.40 % 0 20022 2833 19.61

subset-sum-n1000-r1000-h75of100-s1

1000 objetos · capacidad 375715 · óptimo 375715 · instances/suite-v1/subset-sum-n1000-r1000-h75of100-s1.json

Solver Correctas Mejor GAP mediano GAP mínimo Óptimos Evaluaciones Hasta el mejor ms
exact/dynamic-programming 30/30 375715 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 1 1 284.34
greedy/ratio 30/30 375715 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 1 1 0.05
greedy/ratio-best-item 30/30 375715 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 2 1 0.04
discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 283230 28.40 % 24.62 % 0 698 8 5.67
harmony-search/legacy 30/30 272386 29.11 % 27.50 % 0 698 7 5.99
improved-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 274513 31.02 % 26.94 % 0 118 2 2.07
hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy 30/30 266909 32.15 % 28.96 % 0 22 9 0.14
hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy 30/30 1492 99.60 % 99.60 % 0 20022 2833 19.62

subset-sum-n200-r1000-h25of100-s1

200 objetos · capacidad 25111 · óptimo 25111 · instances/suite-v1/subset-sum-n200-r1000-h25of100-s1.json

Solver Correctas Mejor GAP mediano GAP mínimo Óptimos Evaluaciones Hasta el mejor ms
exact/dynamic-programming 30/30 25111 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 1 1 2.45
greedy/ratio 30/30 25102 0.04 % 0.04 % 0 1 1 0.05
greedy/ratio-best-item 30/30 25102 0.04 % 0.04 % 0 2 1 0.03
harmony-search/legacy 30/30 25107 0.66 % 0.02 % 0 4378 164 4.03
improved-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 25111 0.70 % 0.00 % 1 4447 212 4.05
discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 25110 0.90 % 0.00 % 0 4378 153 3.28
hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy 30/30 1303 94.81 % 94.81 % 0 4022 783 1.23
hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy 0/30 — — — 0 — — —

subset-sum-n200-r1000-h50of100-s1

200 objetos · capacidad 50223 · óptimo 50223 · instances/suite-v1/subset-sum-n200-r1000-h50of100-s1.json

Solver Correctas Mejor GAP mediano GAP mínimo Óptimos Evaluaciones Hasta el mejor ms
exact/dynamic-programming 30/30 50223 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 1 1 6.10
greedy/ratio 30/30 50216 0.01 % 0.01 % 0 1 1 0.03
greedy/ratio-best-item 30/30 50216 0.01 % 0.01 % 0 2 1 0.03
improved-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 50215 0.72 % 0.02 % 0 453 14 0.79
discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 50187 0.78 % 0.07 % 0 341 13 0.56
harmony-search/legacy 30/30 50213 0.87 % 0.02 % 0 344 9 0.65
hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy 30/30 50223 2.45 % 0.00 % 1 24 11 0.05
hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy 30/30 1303 97.41 % 97.41 % 0 4022 783 1.24

subset-sum-n200-r1000-h75of100-s1

200 objetos · capacidad 75335 · óptimo 75335 · instances/suite-v1/subset-sum-n200-r1000-h75of100-s1.json

Solver Correctas Mejor GAP mediano GAP mínimo Óptimos Evaluaciones Hasta el mejor ms
exact/dynamic-programming 30/30 75335 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 1 1 10.99
greedy/ratio 30/30 75314 0.03 % 0.03 % 0 1 1 0.03
greedy/ratio-best-item 30/30 75314 0.03 % 0.03 % 0 2 1 0.04
discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 63058 24.43 % 16.30 % 0 698 7 1.07
harmony-search/legacy 30/30 61204 24.89 % 18.76 % 0 668 8 1.11
improved-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 60938 27.49 % 19.11 % 0 234 2 0.60
hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy 30/30 60689 33.38 % 19.44 % 0 22 9 0.04
hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy 30/30 1303 98.27 % 98.27 % 0 4022 783 1.24

subset-sum-n50-r1000-h25of100-s1

50 objetos · capacidad 6185 · óptimo 6185 · instances/suite-v1/subset-sum-n50-r1000-h25of100-s1.json

Solver Correctas Mejor GAP mediano GAP mínimo Óptimos Evaluaciones Hasta el mejor ms
exact/dynamic-programming 30/30 6185 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 1 1 0.21
greedy/ratio 30/30 6155 0.49 % 0.49 % 0 1 1 0.03
greedy/ratio-best-item 30/30 6155 0.49 % 0.49 % 0 2 1 0.03
hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy 30/30 6173 1.45 % 0.19 % 0 1088 1077 1.34
discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 6185 1.78 % 0.00 % 1 1195 63 0.36
improved-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 6174 2.22 % 0.18 % 0 1293 72 0.44
harmony-search/legacy 30/30 6170 3.25 % 0.24 % 0 1190 46 0.43
hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy 30/30 1020 83.51 % 83.51 % 0 1022 129 0.19

subset-sum-n50-r1000-h50of100-s1

50 objetos · capacidad 12371 · óptimo 12371 · instances/suite-v1/subset-sum-n50-r1000-h50of100-s1.json

Solver Correctas Mejor GAP mediano GAP mínimo Óptimos Evaluaciones Hasta el mejor ms
exact/dynamic-programming 30/30 12371 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 1 1 0.49
greedy/ratio 30/30 12366 0.04 % 0.04 % 0 1 1 0.03
greedy/ratio-best-item 30/30 12366 0.04 % 0.04 % 0 2 1 0.02
improved-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 12367 0.95 % 0.03 % 0 484 24 0.24
discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 12355 1.75 % 0.13 % 0 304 11 0.16
harmony-search/legacy 30/30 12341 2.22 % 0.24 % 0 229 9 0.16
hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy 30/30 12368 4.04 % 0.02 % 0 22 11 0.02
hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy 30/30 1020 91.75 % 91.75 % 0 1022 129 0.19

subset-sum-n50-r1000-h75of100-s1

50 objetos · capacidad 18557 · óptimo 18557 · instances/suite-v1/subset-sum-n50-r1000-h75of100-s1.json

Solver Correctas Mejor GAP mediano GAP mínimo Óptimos Evaluaciones Hasta el mejor ms
exact/dynamic-programming 30/30 18557 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 1 1 0.81
greedy/ratio 30/30 18526 0.17 % 0.17 % 0 1 1 0.04
greedy/ratio-best-item 30/30 18526 0.17 % 0.17 % 0 2 1 0.03
discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 17988 16.70 % 3.07 % 0 638 7 0.29
harmony-search/legacy 30/30 18368 17.16 % 1.02 % 0 578 5 0.28
improved-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 17619 19.32 % 5.05 % 0 408 4 0.22
hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy 30/30 17164 29.85 % 7.51 % 0 22 8 0.02
hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy 30/30 1020 94.50 % 94.50 % 0 1022 129 0.18

uncorrelated-n1000-r1000-h25of100-s1

1000 objetos · capacidad 128820 · óptimo 282852 · instances/suite-v1/uncorrelated-n1000-r1000-h25of100-s1.json

Solver Correctas Mejor GAP mediano GAP mínimo Óptimos Evaluaciones Hasta el mejor ms
exact/dynamic-programming 30/30 282852 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 1 1 108.31
greedy/ratio 30/30 282837 0.01 % 0.01 % 0 1 1 0.18
greedy/ratio-best-item 30/30 282837 0.01 % 0.01 % 0 2 1 0.18
improved-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 139858 54.13 % 50.55 % 0 21460 2017 86.79
harmony-search/legacy 30/30 133452 55.55 % 52.82 % 0 21306 1338 86.12
discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 134327 55.92 % 52.51 % 0 21298 1337 68.74
hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy 30/30 1617 99.43 % 99.43 % 0 20022 2419 19.59
hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy 0/30 — — — 0 — — —

uncorrelated-n1000-r1000-h50of100-s1

1000 objetos · capacidad 257641 · óptimo 402019 · instances/suite-v1/uncorrelated-n1000-r1000-h50of100-s1.json

Solver Correctas Mejor GAP mediano GAP mínimo Óptimos Evaluaciones Hasta el mejor ms
exact/dynamic-programming 30/30 402019 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 1 1 259.98
greedy/ratio 30/30 402019 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 1 1 0.18
greedy/ratio-best-item 30/30 402019 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 2 1 0.18
improved-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 260178 38.56 % 35.28 % 0 714 34 4.90
discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 253789 38.90 % 36.87 % 0 740 19 4.32
harmony-search/legacy 30/30 251102 39.33 % 37.54 % 0 704 28 5.08
hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy 30/30 251593 39.83 % 37.42 % 0 23 12 0.16
hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy 30/30 1617 99.60 % 99.60 % 0 20022 2419 19.57

uncorrelated-n1000-r1000-h75of100-s1

1000 objetos · capacidad 386462 · óptimo 469370 · instances/suite-v1/uncorrelated-n1000-r1000-h75of100-s1.json

Solver Correctas Mejor GAP mediano GAP mínimo Óptimos Evaluaciones Hasta el mejor ms
exact/dynamic-programming 30/30 469370 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 1 1 431.94
greedy/ratio 30/30 469345 0.01 % 0.01 % 0 1 1 0.18
greedy/ratio-best-item 30/30 469345 0.01 % 0.01 % 0 2 1 0.17
harmony-search/legacy 30/30 280196 44.22 % 40.30 % 0 698 7 5.99
discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 271807 44.56 % 42.09 % 0 698 7 5.66
improved-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 266746 46.09 % 43.17 % 0 118 2 2.06
hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy 30/30 271392 47.52 % 42.18 % 0 22 13 0.15
hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy 30/30 1617 99.66 % 99.66 % 0 20022 2419 19.60

uncorrelated-n200-r1000-h25of100-s1

200 objetos · capacidad 25292 · óptimo 54126 · instances/suite-v1/uncorrelated-n200-r1000-h25of100-s1.json

Solver Correctas Mejor GAP mediano GAP mínimo Óptimos Evaluaciones Hasta el mejor ms
exact/dynamic-programming 30/30 54126 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 1 1 4.20
greedy/ratio 30/30 54050 0.14 % 0.14 % 0 1 1 0.06
greedy/ratio-best-item 30/30 54050 0.14 % 0.14 % 0 2 1 0.06
improved-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 29891 52.90 % 44.78 % 0 4631 552 4.21
harmony-search/legacy 30/30 28610 55.02 % 47.14 % 0 4371 145 3.99
discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 27934 55.48 % 48.39 % 0 4369 209 3.28
hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy 30/30 1954 96.39 % 96.39 % 0 4022 629 1.24
hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy 0/30 — — — 0 — — —

uncorrelated-n200-r1000-h50of100-s1

200 objetos · capacidad 50585 · óptimo 76358 · instances/suite-v1/uncorrelated-n200-r1000-h50of100-s1.json

Solver Correctas Mejor GAP mediano GAP mínimo Óptimos Evaluaciones Hasta el mejor ms
exact/dynamic-programming 30/30 76358 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 1 1 9.86
greedy/ratio 30/30 76288 0.09 % 0.09 % 0 1 1 0.06
greedy/ratio-best-item 30/30 76288 0.09 % 0.09 % 0 2 1 0.05
discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 50962 38.71 % 33.26 % 0 382 15 0.58
improved-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 54483 38.76 % 28.65 % 0 474 15 0.83
harmony-search/legacy 30/30 49267 39.39 % 35.48 % 0 354 13 0.66
hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy 30/30 49791 41.79 % 34.79 % 0 22 10 0.04
hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy 30/30 1954 97.44 % 97.44 % 0 4022 629 1.24

uncorrelated-n200-r1000-h75of100-s1

200 objetos · capacidad 75878 · óptimo 89172 · instances/suite-v1/uncorrelated-n200-r1000-h75of100-s1.json

Solver Correctas Mejor GAP mediano GAP mínimo Óptimos Evaluaciones Hasta el mejor ms
exact/dynamic-programming 30/30 89172 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 1 1 16.30
greedy/ratio 30/30 89171 0.00 % 0.00 % 0 1 1 0.06
greedy/ratio-best-item 30/30 89171 0.00 % 0.00 % 0 2 1 0.05
discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 58288 40.43 % 34.63 % 0 698 7 1.07
harmony-search/legacy 30/30 57295 41.57 % 35.75 % 0 698 7 1.13
hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy 30/30 58338 44.07 % 34.58 % 0 22 11 0.04
improved-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 58143 45.07 % 34.80 % 0 234 3 0.63
hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy 30/30 1954 97.81 % 97.81 % 0 4022 629 1.25

uncorrelated-n50-r1000-h25of100-s1

50 objetos · capacidad 6081 · óptimo 14690 · instances/suite-v1/uncorrelated-n50-r1000-h25of100-s1.json

Solver Correctas Mejor GAP mediano GAP mínimo Óptimos Evaluaciones Hasta el mejor ms
exact/dynamic-programming 30/30 14690 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 1 1 0.25
greedy/ratio 30/30 14690 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 1 1 0.04
greedy/ratio-best-item 30/30 14690 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 2 1 0.03
hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy 30/30 11444 41.48 % 22.10 % 0 1104 1099 1.31
improved-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 10044 49.87 % 31.63 % 0 1468 118 0.48
harmony-search/legacy 30/30 9431 54.52 % 35.80 % 0 1172 59 0.42
discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 8219 54.87 % 44.05 % 0 1238 67 0.37
hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy 30/30 1679 88.57 % 88.57 % 0 1022 117 0.20

uncorrelated-n50-r1000-h50of100-s1

50 objetos · capacidad 12162 · óptimo 19915 · instances/suite-v1/uncorrelated-n50-r1000-h50of100-s1.json

Solver Correctas Mejor GAP mediano GAP mínimo Óptimos Evaluaciones Hasta el mejor ms
exact/dynamic-programming 30/30 19915 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 1 1 0.61
greedy/ratio 30/30 19794 0.61 % 0.61 % 0 1 1 0.04
greedy/ratio-best-item 30/30 19794 0.61 % 0.61 % 0 2 1 0.04
improved-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 14859 34.22 % 25.39 % 0 509 17 0.25
discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 14115 36.45 % 29.12 % 0 350 6 0.18
hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy 30/30 14486 37.35 % 27.26 % 0 22 10 0.02
harmony-search/legacy 30/30 14369 38.26 % 27.85 % 0 248 8 0.16
hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy 30/30 1679 91.57 % 91.57 % 0 1022 117 0.19

uncorrelated-n50-r1000-h75of100-s1

50 objetos · capacidad 18244 · óptimo 23551 · instances/suite-v1/uncorrelated-n50-r1000-h75of100-s1.json

Solver Correctas Mejor GAP mediano GAP mínimo Óptimos Evaluaciones Hasta el mejor ms
exact/dynamic-programming 30/30 23551 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 1 1 1.00
greedy/ratio 30/30 23451 0.42 % 0.42 % 0 1 1 0.03
greedy/ratio-best-item 30/30 23451 0.42 % 0.42 % 0 2 1 0.03
harmony-search/legacy 30/30 18997 35.07 % 19.34 % 0 578 4 0.27
discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 17055 36.48 % 27.58 % 0 698 6 0.29
improved-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 18835 38.36 % 20.02 % 0 408 3 0.21
hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy 30/30 17594 40.75 % 25.29 % 0 22 7 0.02
hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy 30/30 1679 92.87 % 92.87 % 0 1022 117 0.19

weakly-correlated-n1000-r1000-h25of100-s1

1000 objetos · capacidad 128820 · óptimo 150569 · instances/suite-v1/weakly-correlated-n1000-r1000-h25of100-s1.json

Solver Correctas Mejor GAP mediano GAP mínimo Óptimos Evaluaciones Hasta el mejor ms
exact/dynamic-programming 30/30 150569 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 1 1 100.91
greedy/ratio 30/30 150560 0.01 % 0.01 % 0 1 1 0.18
greedy/ratio-best-item 30/30 150560 0.01 % 0.01 % 0 2 1 0.18
improved-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 130925 13.77 % 13.05 % 0 21339 1374 86.36
discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 131228 13.87 % 12.85 % 0 21284 770 69.07
harmony-search/legacy 30/30 130810 13.97 % 13.12 % 0 21204 771 85.98
hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy 30/30 1434 99.05 % 99.05 % 0 20022 2493 19.59
hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy 0/30 — — — 0 — — —

weakly-correlated-n1000-r1000-h50of100-s1

1000 objetos · capacidad 257641 · óptimo 284888 · instances/suite-v1/weakly-correlated-n1000-r1000-h50of100-s1.json

Solver Correctas Mejor GAP mediano GAP mínimo Óptimos Evaluaciones Hasta el mejor ms
exact/dynamic-programming 30/30 284888 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 1 1 247.47
greedy/ratio 30/30 284867 0.01 % 0.01 % 0 1 1 0.17
greedy/ratio-best-item 30/30 284867 0.01 % 0.01 % 0 2 1 0.17
improved-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 261081 9.09 % 8.36 % 0 761 32 5.15
discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 260859 9.17 % 8.43 % 0 723 27 4.04
harmony-search/legacy 30/30 261664 9.24 % 8.15 % 0 720 27 5.00
hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy 30/30 259435 11.01 % 8.93 % 0 22 11 0.17
hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy 30/30 1434 99.50 % 99.50 % 0 20022 2493 19.60

weakly-correlated-n1000-r1000-h75of100-s1

1000 objetos · capacidad 386462 · óptimo 409104 · instances/suite-v1/weakly-correlated-n1000-r1000-h75of100-s1.json

Solver Correctas Mejor GAP mediano GAP mínimo Óptimos Evaluaciones Hasta el mejor ms
exact/dynamic-programming 30/30 409104 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 1 1 415.84
greedy/ratio 30/30 409093 0.00 % 0.00 % 0 1 1 0.17
greedy/ratio-best-item 30/30 409093 0.00 % 0.00 % 0 2 1 0.17
discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 286430 32.16 % 29.99 % 0 698 6 5.67
harmony-search/legacy 30/30 292250 32.37 % 28.56 % 0 698 6 5.97
improved-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 285963 35.10 % 30.10 % 0 118 1 2.07
hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy 30/30 292649 35.14 % 28.47 % 0 22 13 0.14
hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy 30/30 1434 99.65 % 99.65 % 0 20022 2493 19.62

weakly-correlated-n200-r1000-h25of100-s1

200 objetos · capacidad 25292 · óptimo 29526 · instances/suite-v1/weakly-correlated-n200-r1000-h25of100-s1.json

Solver Correctas Mejor GAP mediano GAP mínimo Óptimos Evaluaciones Hasta el mejor ms
exact/dynamic-programming 30/30 29526 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 1 1 4.07
greedy/ratio 30/30 29489 0.13 % 0.13 % 0 1 1 0.06
greedy/ratio-best-item 30/30 29489 0.13 % 0.13 % 0 2 1 0.06
improved-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 26236 13.63 % 11.14 % 0 4460 270 4.05
discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 25876 14.68 % 12.36 % 0 4413 177 3.31
harmony-search/legacy 30/30 26154 14.83 % 11.42 % 0 4356 220 4.03
hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy 30/30 1567 94.69 % 94.69 % 0 4022 595 1.24
hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy 0/30 — — — 0 — — —

weakly-correlated-n200-r1000-h50of100-s1

200 objetos · capacidad 50585 · óptimo 56025 · instances/suite-v1/weakly-correlated-n200-r1000-h50of100-s1.json

Solver Correctas Mejor GAP mediano GAP mínimo Óptimos Evaluaciones Hasta el mejor ms
exact/dynamic-programming 30/30 56025 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 1 1 9.65
greedy/ratio 30/30 56013 0.02 % 0.02 % 0 1 1 0.06
greedy/ratio-best-item 30/30 56013 0.02 % 0.02 % 0 2 1 0.06
improved-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 51226 10.16 % 8.57 % 0 482 19 0.84
discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 51301 10.63 % 8.43 % 0 341 16 0.57
harmony-search/legacy 30/30 51044 10.73 % 8.89 % 0 361 15 0.67
hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy 30/30 51035 12.05 % 8.91 % 0 23 14 0.05
hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy 30/30 1567 97.20 % 97.20 % 0 4022 595 1.25

weakly-correlated-n200-r1000-h75of100-s1

200 objetos · capacidad 75878 · óptimo 80271 · instances/suite-v1/weakly-correlated-n200-r1000-h75of100-s1.json

Solver Correctas Mejor GAP mediano GAP mínimo Óptimos Evaluaciones Hasta el mejor ms
exact/dynamic-programming 30/30 80271 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 1 1 15.95
greedy/ratio 30/30 80207 0.08 % 0.08 % 0 1 1 0.06
greedy/ratio-best-item 30/30 80207 0.08 % 0.08 % 0 2 1 0.06
discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 61707 29.34 % 23.13 % 0 698 6 1.07
harmony-search/legacy 30/30 62302 29.47 % 22.39 % 0 698 6 1.13
improved-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 65191 30.69 % 18.79 % 0 234 2 0.61
hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy 30/30 63152 34.68 % 21.33 % 0 22 11 0.04
hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy 30/30 1567 98.05 % 98.05 % 0 4022 595 1.24

weakly-correlated-n50-r1000-h25of100-s1

50 objetos · capacidad 6081 · óptimo 7000 · instances/suite-v1/weakly-correlated-n50-r1000-h25of100-s1.json

Solver Correctas Mejor GAP mediano GAP mínimo Óptimos Evaluaciones Hasta el mejor ms
exact/dynamic-programming 30/30 7000 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 1 1 0.25
greedy/ratio 30/30 6946 0.77 % 0.77 % 0 1 1 0.03
greedy/ratio-best-item 30/30 6946 0.77 % 0.77 % 0 2 1 0.03
improved-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 6428 13.50 % 8.17 % 0 1370 99 0.47
hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy 30/30 6326 14.84 % 9.63 % 0 573 569 0.70
harmony-search/legacy 30/30 6502 16.34 % 7.11 % 0 1201 51 0.42
discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 6302 17.54 % 9.97 % 0 1232 44 0.37
hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy 30/30 1890 73.00 % 73.00 % 0 1022 203 0.20

weakly-correlated-n50-r1000-h50of100-s1

50 objetos · capacidad 12162 · óptimo 13290 · instances/suite-v1/weakly-correlated-n50-r1000-h50of100-s1.json

Solver Correctas Mejor GAP mediano GAP mínimo Óptimos Evaluaciones Hasta el mejor ms
exact/dynamic-programming 30/30 13290 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 1 1 0.61
greedy/ratio 30/30 13289 0.01 % 0.01 % 0 1 1 0.04
greedy/ratio-best-item 30/30 13289 0.01 % 0.01 % 0 2 1 0.04
improved-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 12385 9.53 % 6.81 % 0 451 12 0.24
discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 12100 11.74 % 8.95 % 0 339 9 0.18
hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy 30/30 12304 12.16 % 7.42 % 0 23 12 0.02
harmony-search/legacy 30/30 12244 14.24 % 7.87 % 0 261 10 0.17
hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy 30/30 1890 85.78 % 85.78 % 0 1022 203 0.19

weakly-correlated-n50-r1000-h75of100-s1

50 objetos · capacidad 18244 · óptimo 19069 · instances/suite-v1/weakly-correlated-n50-r1000-h75of100-s1.json

Solver Correctas Mejor GAP mediano GAP mínimo Óptimos Evaluaciones Hasta el mejor ms
exact/dynamic-programming 30/30 19069 0.00 % 0.00 % 30 1 1 0.99
greedy/ratio 30/30 19040 0.15 % 0.15 % 0 1 1 0.04
greedy/ratio-best-item 30/30 19040 0.15 % 0.15 % 0 2 1 0.03
discrete-binary-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 16904 22.78 % 11.35 % 0 638 4 0.28
harmony-search/legacy 30/30 17050 23.53 % 10.59 % 0 578 5 0.28
improved-harmony-search/legacy 30/30 17292 24.58 % 9.32 % 0 466 3 0.22
hill-climbing-first-ascent/legacy 30/30 17134 28.36 % 10.15 % 0 22 10 0.02
hill-climbing-best-ascent/legacy 30/30 1890 90.09 % 90.09 % 0 1022 203 0.20